How we built the provider comparison
We requested Q1 2026 quotes from eight UK underwriters for four representative profiles, then cross-checked premium ranges and excesses against published broker data from BIBA member firms. We are not paid by any insurer named below.
Side-by-side: leading UK providers
Why we compare these four providers
We compare Hiscox, Aviva, AXA and Direct Line because each holds ≥3% UK classic car insurance market share (ABI 2025), publishes payout-ratio data, and is directly authorised by the FCA. We exclude MGAs and brokers from this table because their pricing is panel-dependent and not directly comparable. We are not paid for inclusion or placement.
| Insurer | Coverage | Avg premium | Claims payout | ABI member | FCA regulated |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Hiscox | Comprehensive | £180–£420 | 98.2% | ||
| Aviva | Standard + | £155–£380 | 97.5% | ||
| AXA | Standard | £140–£360 | 96.8% | ||
| Direct Line | Basic + | £120–£330 | 96.1% |
FCA Regulated ABI MemberPremium ranges based on InsuranceDico Q1 2026 broker survey, n = 8.
WARNING
Headline premium is the wrong anchor. A £120 policy with a £1m limit and a £1,000 excess is more expensive in any real claim than a £180 policy with £5m and a £250 excess. Compare on net exposure, not sticker price.
Decision Framework
Which classic car insurance policy should you choose?
If you are a…
Sole trader, low-risk trade
Direct Line or AXA
Lowest premium bands; £1m–£2m limit is sufficient.
If you are a…
Growing SME, 5–25 staff
Aviva
Mid-market wording, broker-friendly claims, £5m limit standard.
If you are a…
Specialist / regulated trade
Hiscox
Bespoke wordings cover activities standard policies exclude.
If you are a…
Contract-driven business
Hiscox or Aviva (£10m)
Many UK commercial contracts demand £10m PL minimum.
Ready to compare actual quotes?
We use a panel-based affiliate to source live UK quotes. We earn a small fee if you buy, your premium is unchanged.
Compare quotes from these providers →